(Every Sunday we will break down Notre Dame fan theories and scenarios. From player transfers and recruits to the future of Notre Dame football. Send a question you would like us to feature at firstname.lastname@example.org or leave it in the comments below.)
The narrative was started long ago and the playoff just fanned the flames. After Notre Dame drops yet another big game in the Brian Kelly era, its worth asking, what is next for Brian Kelly?
Kelly has been a hot button topic for Notre Dame fans for years. He has done enough to make Notre Dame relevant but they always seem to fall apart in the big moments. So it really comes down to if Notre Dame would be better off moving on from Brian Kelly. To answer that you really have to wonder who would replace him.
Notre Dame would need to find a high profile coach to replace Brian Kelly if he were to get fired, but is Notre Dame still a high profiled job? It has history, great facilities and a rabid fan base. But it also has tough academics and won’t let players skate by.
It wasn’t long ago that Notre Dame suspended their starting QB for cheating on a mid term. I could be wrong but I don’t think a school like that buys into the win at all costs even if you have to cheat. The rumors have swirled around college sports about their athletes being paid and getting gifts to come to certain schools. When Hugh Freeze was busted at Ole Miss, a few anonymous sources said the entire SEC knew Freeze was buying recruits. The issue was they were doing the same.
I’m not saying that every school cheats or you have to cheat to be successful, you don’t. But Notre Dame also takes the student athlete tag very seriously and it would scare some coaches off. Notre Dame could still be an elite program and I would say they are still a blue chip school. But the deck is stacked against them is the point I am trying to make.
Brian Kelly isn’t a top three coach but he is a damn good coach when looking at college football. Brian Kelly should stay at Notre Dame for the foreseeable future if he chooses to. Charlie Weis was considered a big get as a coach coming from New England. With Brian Kelly you know what you have and generally know what you get.
This is a coach that will keep a team in the hunt and every few years put a dream season together. His legacy is also not set in stone, he can still get a win and has shown growth and progress the last two years. Things look bleak after a blowout loss but just take a step back and look at the entire picture. An undefeated season and a team that got to their first playoff berth. Clemson has been there the last few seasons and was ready for the moment. This is a moment to learn and grow so dumping Kelly means a total start over. Kelly may or may not be the answer, but what superstar coach is beating Notre Dame’s door down?
Let us know what you think below! Is Brian Kelly the coach of the future or does Notre Dame need to move on?
Started Saturday Tailgate in 2018. Covering all things college football and talking Notre Dame on Twitter.